insights

Managing Price Risk in Commercial Contracts

How Belgian Law Balances Commercial Certainty and Economic Reality

In recent years, businesses have had to navigate an increasingly unpredictable economic environment. The COVID-19 pandemic, supply chain disruptions, the war in Ukraine, the ensuing energy crisis, persistent inflation and broader geopolitical tensions have all contributed to significant cost increases throughout many industries. More recently, renewed instability in the Middle East, disruptions to global shipping routes and the reintroduction of U.S. trade tariffs have created additional pressure on international supply chains, increasing the cost of raw materials, transportation and cross-border trade.

For many companies, this raises a practical question: can a supplier increase its prices after a contract has already been signed? Equally, customers may wonder whether they are entitled to insist on the originally agreed price despite rapidly changing market conditions.

The answer is rarely straightforward. While Belgian law provides certain mechanisms to deal with exceptional circumstances, the starting point remains clear: a contract is meant to be honoured. Whether a price can be adjusted depends first and foremost on the contractual arrangements agreed between the parties, and only in exceptional cases on the law itself.

The contract always comes first

One of the cornerstones of Belgian contract law is that agreements are binding on the parties. Once a contract has been concluded, each party is expected to perform its obligations as agreed, including respecting the agreed pricing.

The price is one of the fundamental elements of any commercial agreement. It must be determined, or at least capable of being determined, when the contract is concluded. Once the contract is in force, neither party is free to rewrite the commercial bargain simply because market conditions have changed.

In practice, this means that a supplier cannot simply increase its prices because labour, energy or raw material costs have become more expensive. Likewise, a customer cannot demand a price reduction merely because market prices have fallen.

Commercial risk is generally considered part of doing business. Unless the parties have agreed otherwise, fluctuations in operating costs normally remain the responsibility of the party performing the contract.

This is why the first question should never be whether costs have increased. Instead, businesses should ask a far more important question:

What does the contract actually say?

A well-drafted price adjustment clause is your best protection

The most effective way to manage future price fluctuations is to anticipate them before the contract is signed.

A carefully drafted price adjustment clause allows the parties to adapt the contract price throughout its duration according to objective and predefined criteria. Rather than forcing parties into difficult renegotiations every time the market changes, such clauses provide predictability and reduce the risk of disputes.

However, not every price adjustment mechanism will achieve this objective. An effective clause should clearly address several practical questions, including:

  • which cost elements may justify a price adjustment;
  • which objective indicators will be used;
  • how the revised price will be calculated;
  • when adjustments may take place;
  • whether the adjustment operates automatically or only upon request;
  • what supporting documentation, if any, must be provided; and
  • whether the mechanism operates for both price increases and price decreases.

The more precisely these elements are defined, the less room there is for disagreement during the life of the contract.

For businesses entering into long-term supply, manufacturing, logistics or service agreements, investing time in drafting an appropriate price review mechanism is often far less expensive than resolving disputes later.

Belgian law imposes limits on price adjustment clauses

Although Belgian law generally respects contractual freedom, businesses do not enjoy unlimited discretion when drafting price adjustment mechanisms.

In many commercial contracts, price revision clauses remain subject to specific statutory requirements designed to prevent abusive or purely speculative pricing mechanisms.

As a general rule, a valid price adjustment clause should be based on objective cost factors that genuinely affect the supplier’s costs, such as labour, raw materials, energy, transport costs or, where relevant, exchange rate fluctuations.

By contrast, automatic indexation based solely on general inflation indices, such as the consumer price index or health index, is generally prohibited for commercial and industrial prices subject to the relevant legislation.

Belgian law also requires a degree of proportionality. A particular cost parameter should only affect the portion of the contract price that genuinely relates to that cost element. Suppose that steel represents approximately 25% of the manufacturing cost of a product. A rise in steel prices should normally affect only that portion of the contract price, rather than the contract price as a whole. Businesses nevertheless retain a reasonable degree of flexibility when determining how different cost elements are weighted, provided the allocation remains commercially realistic.

Furthermore, not every part of the agreed price may be revised. As a general principle, no more than 80% of the agreed contract price may be made variable through a price adjustment mechanism, meaning that at least 20% of the price must remain fixed.

Another important requirement is reciprocity. A price adjustment mechanism should operate in both directions. If objective costs decrease, the revised price should also be capable of decreasing. Clauses that only allow upward adjustments are more likely to be challenged.

Failure to comply with these requirements may render the price adjustment clause unenforceable.

It is worth noting, however, that these rules do not apply universally. Certain sectors, specific categories of contracts and public procurement agreements are subject to different legal regimes. International contracts may also require a separate analysis depending on the governing law and the place of performance.

Unilateral price increases deserve particular attention

Even where no formal price adjustment clause exists, some businesses include provisions allowing one party to modify prices unilaterally. Such clauses should be approached with caution.

Belgian B2B legislation seeks to prevent significant contractual imbalances between businesses. As a result, contractual provisions allowing one party to change the agreed price without a legitimate and objectively justifiable reason may be considered unfair and therefore unenforceable.

This does not necessarily mean that unilateral price adjustments are always prohibited. Rather, the contractual mechanism should be transparent, based on objective and verifiable criteria and drafted in a manner that allows both parties to understand the circumstances in which a price change may occur.

The more discretion one party retains without meaningful contractual safeguards, the greater the legal risk.

Can exceptional circumstances justify changing the contract?

Not every contract contains a price review clause. In those situations, businesses sometimes look to general principles of contract law for relief. Belgian law recognises two distinct legal concepts that may become relevant when unforeseen events disrupt contractual performance: force majeure and hardship (imprévision).

Although these concepts are often mentioned together, they serve very different purposes.

Force majeure

Force majeure applies where an unforeseen event makes contractual performance genuinely impossible.

The threshold is intentionally high. It is not sufficient that performance has become more expensive, commercially unattractive or less profitable. Rising energy prices, increased labour costs or inflation will rarely constitute force majeure on their own.

Only where external circumstances make performance objectively impossible, rather than merely more burdensome, may a party invoke force majeure. Depending on the circumstances, contractual obligations may then be suspended temporarily or, in exceptional cases, terminated altogether.

Businesses should also remember that contracts frequently contain notification requirements governing how and when force majeure must be invoked. Failure to comply with those procedural obligations may jeopardise reliance on the clause.

Hardship (imprévision)

Hardship addresses a different situation.

Performance remains possible, but unforeseen circumstances have fundamentally altered the economic balance of the contract, making continued performance excessively onerous for one party.

Belgian law now recognises hardship as a legal mechanism for contracts concluded from 1 January 2023 onwards, unless the parties have contractually excluded its application.

The conditions remain deliberately strict. The change of circumstances must have been genuinely unforeseeable, the affected party must not have caused the situation or assumed the relevant risk under the contract, and the economic impact must go well beyond ordinary commercial fluctuations.

Where these conditions are met, the disadvantaged party may request that the contract be renegotiated. Importantly, the existing contractual obligations generally continue during those negotiations. If the parties cannot reach agreement within a reasonable period, the courts may ultimately intervene by adapting or, in exceptional circumstances, terminating the contract.

Hardship should therefore be regarded as a safety net rather than an alternative to careful contractual drafting.

Good faith still matters

Belgian contract law also requires parties to perform their agreements in good faith.

Recent case law has demonstrated that, in exceptional circumstances, courts may expect parties to engage in genuine discussions where unforeseen events have fundamentally disrupted the contractual balance.

This does not create a general right to revise agreed prices, nor does it allow parties to escape a poor commercial bargain. However, it reflects an increasing expectation that businesses act reasonably and constructively when confronted with truly exceptional circumstances.

Commercial dialogue will often achieve a faster, more cost-effective and commercially sustainable outcome than immediate litigation.

Practical recommendations for businesses

Price disputes often arise not because the law is unclear, but because contracts fail to anticipate changing market conditions. Whether you act as supplier or customer, several practical measures can significantly reduce legal and commercial risk.

Review your existing contract portfolio. Long-term agreements concluded before recent inflationary periods may no longer allocate economic risk appropriately.  Avoid generic wording. Clauses stating that prices may be adjusted “if costs increase” provide little legal certainty and are more likely to generate disputes.

Define objective cost drivers. Identify the specific components that may trigger a price adjustment and establish a clear calculation methodology, including how different cost components are weighted.

Document cost increases carefully. Businesses requesting a price revision should retain supporting evidence demonstrating the actual impact of increased costs.

Consider hardship provisions. Depending on the nature and duration of the commercial relationship, a contractual hardship clause may provide greater flexibility than relying solely on statutory rules. The contract should in any event clarify whether the statutory hardship regime is excluded, supplemented or left to apply.

Do not wait until the relationship deteriorates. Early commercial discussions often produce better outcomes than formal legal disputes once performance has become financially unsustainable.

The key message

Many businesses assume that rising costs automatically justify higher prices. Under Belgian law, this is generally not the case. The legal answer depends far less on today’s market conditions than on the contractual framework negotiated yesterday.

Businesses that proactively address pricing risks through carefully drafted contractual provisions are generally far better positioned than those forced to rely on statutory exceptions after problems have already arisen.

In an environment where economic volatility has become the norm rather than the exception, robust contract drafting is no longer merely a legal exercise. It has become an essential element of commercial risk management.

At LexPrime Consulting, we regularly assist businesses in reviewing commercial contracts, negotiating balanced price adjustment mechanisms and managing disputes arising from changing economic circumstances. A proactive legal review before signing a contract often proves significantly less costly than resolving disagreements once performance is underway.